Electric fields bring new dimension to debate on atomic size



International Conference on Nuclear Physics 


How big is an atom? On the order of ångströms, scientists agree, but putting a precise figure on a given element is trickier. For ions and molecules, even more so.

Answers have been offered from a variety of empirical sources, with everything from compressibility and crystal structure to optical refraction and electrical polarity being used to quantify what is known as the Van der Waals radius – named after the scientist who theorised finite molecular size in gases. Researchers have also turned to quantum mechanics and computation, calculating electron wavefunctions – the clouds of probability that surround atoms – and using a sensible cut-off value to mark out an atomic boundary.





A team at the University of Oregon, US, has now proposed a new metric: the electric field that surrounds every atom. Led by Christopher Hendon, they have developed a software package to calculate this electric field, which arises under the net influence of the atom’s nucleus and electrons, and quantify its extent in space.

For neutral, non-interacting atoms, the charge of the electrons balances the nucleus, cancelling out the electric field beyond. Indeed, using their field-based method, the team’s calculations were in line with established values. ‘We match closely to the accepted Van der Waals radii,’ says Hendon. ‘That’s a good sanity check.’

Figure

Source: © Christopher Hendon/University of Oregon

Conventional chemical tenets suggested by Batsanov would indicate that Mg2+, and cations in general, are smaller than their neutral counterparts. Yet, from an electrical field perspective, Mg2+ should be significantly larger than Mg0, because the electric field ultimately depends on the ratio of the number of protons-to-electrons



Ions are where, in Hendon’s words, the model ‘really takes a turn for the interesting’, as illustrated for the case of Mg2+. Under the conventional measure of electron density, this cation is more compact than its neutral counterpart, due to lacking its outer electrons. The electric field picture, however, shows a size increase. This is because the nuclear charge is no longer fully screened by the electrons, so the field can pervade further into space.

The advantage of this approach, Hendon argues, is that it corresponds to the region that the ion affects, which could be more relevant than the region it occupies, especially when choosing materials for applications. The result for Mg2+, he suggests, might explain why magnesium-ion batteries do not perform well. ‘The magnesium sticks to everything… It doesn’t move that easily, unlike other ions.’

For anions too, the model draws surprising conclusions, not least when comparing elements. Under the field-based model, a Br- ion turns out to be larger than I-, and F- is bigger still. This reversal comes about because the extra electron on a bromide ion has its field reined in by the larger nucleus. ‘You’re basically diluting the negative charge by more positive species,’ Hendon explains.

Santiago Alvarez, an electronic structure expert at the University of Barcelona, Spain, cautions against too literal an interpretation. ‘To compare with a macroscopic situation, would we define the size of a magnet as the extent of some cut-off of its magnetic field?’ he asks.

Alvarez, who has also worked on quantifying atomic size, points out that the electric field is only one means by which nearby atoms can interact, with Pauling repulsion, orbital dispersion and spin–spin interactions being others. And he highlights complications that may arise when atoms form bonds: ‘How could we apply the radius of Fe3+ [calculated by Hendon’s team as approximately 4.2Å], to species such as the FeO45- anion, in which the oxygen atoms are barely 1.90Å from the iron nucleus?’

Hendon is keen to stress that his approach should complement, not replace, the existing ones. ‘The Van der Waals radii are backed up by experimental data. This has been extremely valuable.’

#Electricity .

#RenewableEnergy

#ElectricVehicles

#SmartGrid

#EnergyEfficiency

#ElectricityStorage

#Electricians

#Electronics

#IoT



https://www.tumblr.com/settings/blog/nuclearconferences
https://www.tumblr.com/settings/blog/nuclearconferences
https://in.pinterest.com/nuclearconferences/_saved/

https://www.linkedin.com/in/aman-deep-aa1319268/

https://twitter.com/AmanDee71996637

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Shape-shifting experiment challenges interpretation of how cadmium nuclei move

Image
Atomic nuclei take a range of shapes, from spherical (like a basketball) to deformed (like an American football). Spherical nuclei are often described by the motion of a small fraction of the protons and neutrons, while deformed nuclei tend to rotate as a collective whole. A third kind of motion has been proposed since the 1950s. In this motion, known as nuclear vibration, atomic nuclei fluctuate about an average shape. Scientists recently investigated cadmium-106 using a technique called Coulomb excitation to probe its nuclear shape . They found clear experimental evidence that the vibrational description fails for this isotope's nucleus. This finding is counter to the expected results. Research published in Physics Letters B builds on a long quest to understand the transition between spherical and deformed nuclei . This transition often includes vibrational motion as an intermediate step. The new result suggests that nuclear physicists may need to revise the long-standing para...
Read more

HOMESPACE NEWS Mysterious Physics Revealed: “One of the Most Violent Events You Can Imagine in the Universe”

Image
Recent simulations of two black holes colliding at close to the speed of light have shed light on the enigmatic physics behind what has been called by one astrophysicist as “one of the most violent events you can imagine in the universe.” The findings, published in Physical Review Letters, is the first detailed look at the aftermath of such a cataclysmic clash, and shows how a remnant black hole would form and send gravitational waves through the cosmos. Black hole mergers are one of the few events in the universe energetic enough to produce detectable gravitational waves, which carry energy produced by massive cosmic collisions. Like ripples in a pond, these waves flow through the universe distorting space and time. But unlike waves traveling through water, they are extremely tiny, and propagate through “spacetime,” the mind-bending concept that combines the three dimensions of space with the idea of time. This simulation shows two black holes colliding near the speed of light, revea...
Read more

Nuclear power: The safer and cheaper alternative to fossil fuels

Image
As countries across the globe struggle to balance their desire for a reliable energy supply with their contribution to climate change, nuclear power presents a solution. The global reliance on fossil fuels is a function of our energy needs, and although there have been numerous initiatives implemented in order to reduce demand, such as levying large taxes on air transport, appropriate sources of supply still need to be defined. Fossil fuels such as coal, oil and gas have the benefit of being capable of servicing our energy needs. However, they are a chief contributor to climate change, and as countries attempt to meet the Paris Agreement of keeping global temperature below 2o above pre-industrial levels, non-carbon energy sources are essential. Positives and negatives So, what are the pros and cons of nuclear power as a safer, cheaper alternative to fossil fuels? Well, where renewable sources such as wind or solar are clean, they are also intermittent, require an uneven geographical ...
Read more